en gruppe mennesker som poserer for et bilde foran et bord

Recap of Cloud Stories from Norway, Episode 6: Migrating 120 VMs to Azure in 1.5 months in TINE

Maxim Salnikov

Maxim Salnikov

Developer Engagement Lead

Lesetid, 8 min.

The next episode of the “Cloud stories from Norway” videoshow is ready for watching! In this 40-minutes long show we feature Azure cloud best practices, patterns, tips & tricks used in production in the products and services of well-known Norwegian companies.

For this episode, Maxim Salnikov from Microsoft invited Jan Egil Ring, a Lead Architect at Crayon – an important partner of Microsoft, that helps Norwegian and not only companies to build and operate cloud projects, and Morten Hansen, an Infrastructure Architect at TINE – the largest Norwegian dairy product cooperative consisting of around 15 000 farmers and more than 5 000 employees. From two short, focused tech sessions you will learn about

  • Best practices and findings during the migrating of 120 VMs to Azure in just 1.5 months
  • What other projects on Azure are under development in TINE and Crayon
  • Many more cloud tips & tricks to skill you up on cloud technologies!

The video is available online, you can watch it here: On-demand

We received many technical questions during event, here are the answers on some of them:

How did you do in order to get a cost estimate for the Azure related costs for this migration? Could you use the TCO calculator in Azure?We used Azure Migrate to perform an initial assessment of the whole datacenter, and then broke it down to the VMs that was in scope for the migration project. The assessment feature in Azure Migrate is really good and allows you to select factors such as region, reserved instances and so on. For common infrastructure costs like ExpressRoute which was implemented in the same time frame we used the Azure Pricing calculator. Although, the Azure TCO Calculator you mentioned very useful in order to account for all costs such as datacenter operations, so you get a good insights into Total Cost of Ownership.
Have you adopted ‘subscription democratization’ principle from the Enterprise-Scale or have you chosen to retain a full control of subscriptons within central IT? If the latter one, what were the main reasons?Central IT is in charge of common «infrastructure subscriptions» such as the hub subscription (ExpressRoute, domain controllers and such) & the landing zone for the AMP project. Others subscriptions are created on a business unit basis where central IT provides some control with regards to networking and access controls – using Azure AD PIM and RBAC to provide access for application owners, vendors and so on.
Regarding your monitoring strategy: have you moved SCOM VMs ‘as-is’ to Azure or have you adopted cloud native tools with Azure Monitor, Log Analytics, workbooks, etc.?SCOM VMs was moved as-is, and is mainly used for monitoring the datacenter and the ~30 production plants. For new cloud native services, Azure Monitor is being leveraged as the primary tool of choice. One of the reasons of continuing the usage of SCOM is that Tine already have invested a lot of time and efforts in the SCOM infrastructure, using SquaredUp on top for dashboarding. Also, Azure Monitor is not so suitable for all existing technologies in Windows Server such as Failover Clustering and so on. Tine us using Azure Arc for all on-premises servers though, so we might look into the new Azure Monitoring agent deployed via Arc at some point.
How big was the project teams from Crayon and Tine and how was it (rougly) divided in terms of technical competency areas?The project team was 5-6 persons working with priority. And we had the possibility to get help from others since this project was important to TINE.
Was the main reason for chosing Azure vs competitors that Azure had/created server locations in Norway?That was one of the main reasons. We needed fast response times to different services, for instance database and integrations services. The response times in Norway compared to outside Norway was noticeable: ~20-25 ms to West Europe, ~4-5 ms to Norway East with VPN and ~2-3 ms to Norway East with ExpressRoute.
I see that you used a hub & spoke architecture and that you used different vnets for the spokes. How would it work with using subnets instead of vnets? How much cost would it save and would it be worth it?If using one large VNet divided into multiple subnets instead of carving out multiple VNets, one would have been tied to a single subscription as a VNet cannot span multiple subscriptions. As a VNet itself doesn`t incur any cost, I don`t believe the cost difference would be much (if anything). There are other elements to think of when moving the discussion to one subscription vs many. A single subscription for an Enterprise is considered an anti-pattern in the Cloud Adoption Framework. There are many reasons for this discussed in the framework, but one thing to consider is that a subscription is «a unit of scale». There is a certain amount of virtual Cores, virtual machines and so on available by default within a subscription. To go above these, one must file a quota increase request and detail the demand now and in the coming 6-12 months. Even though the cloud is «limitless», there are some boundaries in practice – so planning is key.
About backup solution, what do you recommend when you have servers running on prem as well as in Azure? Good to have 2 solution or just one azure solution for all servers?It depends whether there are any existing backup solution in place on-premises which makes sense to continue or not, but in general we backup services where they run with regards to RTOs. For on-premises, we also leverage the Azure Backup integration in System Center DPM both for off-site storage and for long-term retention (it replaced tape-based backups 6-7 years ago). In you have a greenfield environment and do not have any System Center DPM licenses, you could use Azure Backup Server which is essentially the same product, but with a difference licensing model (tied to an Azure subscription instead of a System Center licence). That is, if you are keen to leverage a Microsoft product for on-premises backups – which makes sense when using Windows Server and other Microsoft products. There are Azure backup/storage integrations in 3rd party product such as Veeam as well.
A question for Morten: Can you give a ball park figure on the cost or time savings this project has given you?The cost savings is just for TIP is just for the project work itself between 100000-200000, in addition to time saved with regards to being able to deliver infrastructure on-demand. We also would have needed more servers on-prem. Since we have 2 datacenters we saved 2 more physical servers approx 350000,- in addition. And that is only for TIP. We also have some minor projects that has given cost savings. BUT: In addition we have gained so much better control and documentation. Cost is of course important, but using Tags to document and work in a better way gives a lot of ‘unexpected’ savings. And also, to turn off servers between 22:00-07:00 (test environments for instance) saves us money. For production workloads which needs 24/7 availability, we are using Reserved Instances which saves a significant amount over 3 years.
Hi! Was Azure Migration tool used to the purpose of getting an overall insight of the on-prem infrastructure?The AMP project main purpose was to move servers, but it also gave us one advantage we have not thought about: When system owners were asked if servers had to run 24/7 or if they were critical we actually managed to remove some of the servers as well. The tool also helped us get a better overview of the ON-prem environment.
How can new organizations learn from Crayon journey and working towards the UN sustainability goals?I recommend to read this regarding goals: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/corporate-responsibility/un-sustainable-development-goals
How fast is Azure (spinning up VM’s, generating tags, web client performance etc) vs competitors?In the past, provisioning VMs was a bit slower than the competiton, but after implementing a new feature where I believe there are «hot standby» VMs waiting for customizations in the backend it has improved significantly. Typically when provisioning a Windows VM using a Terraform template, it completes in ~3 minutes. Linux is faster (depending on distro). For other services I haven`t made any comparisons, but in genereal it varies a lot by service. It is also enhanced in newer versions, for example Application Gateway deploys in ~25 minutes vs ~45 minutes in the V2 SKU vs the V1 SKU IIRC.

Stay tuned for the next episode of the “Cloud stories from Norway”!

How to follow all Microsoft Norway’s and local tech communities’ events about Azure cloud for the developers – conferences, seminars, workshops, training, webinars, etc.? Just follow our technical twitter https://twitter.com/MSDevNo

To stay connected:

 

Feel free to send your questions about the Azure cloud technology and educational events here: maxim.salnikov@microsoft.com

Maxim Salnikov

Developer Engagement Lead at Microsoft Norway

 

All episodes of “Cloud stories from Norway»

Kostnadsfri e-bok: La de ansatte være kreative og samarbeide trygt

Opplev vekst i en raskt skiftende digital verden ved å gi de ansatte friheten og fleksibiliteten til å være produktiv og samarbeide fra hvor som helst

Oppdag flere relaterte artikler per bransje:

Detaljhandel

Helseomsorg

  • en person som sitter foran en bærbar datamaskin

    «Big Bang»-tilnærmingen til digital transformasjon – og hvordan man får den til å fungere

    Ingenting er som før for næringsdrivende. Endring og omveltning er den nye normalen. Bare tenk på endringene som påvirker din egen organisasjon akkurat nå: Ny teknologi og nye teknikker skaper nye holdninger og forventninger både blant ansatte og kunder. Alt forandrer seg. Det eneste alle endringene har til felles, er hastigheten de skjer i. De […]

  • Datadrevet helse-Norge

    Datadrevet helse-Norge

    Fredag 22. januar, hadde vi en direktesendt event om bruken av Power BI i helseregionene- og foretakene, og hvordan din organisasjon kan dele innsikt på en sikker måte på tvers av applikasjoner og samhandlingsverktøy.   Denne bloggposten inkluderer presentasjonene fra foredragsholderne og spørsmålene fra eventet. Foredragsholderne og presentasjoner:   Helseregionene: «PowerBI i Helse Sør-Øst» av Lars Rønning – Analysesjef i Helse Sør-Øst «Datadrevet helse-Norge – bruk av […]

Industri

  • en gruppe mennesker i et rom

    Open Innovation Cruise

    Microsoft Norway’s startup team and Sopra Steria Scale up organized Open Innovation Cruise 2019 on October 15th to October 17th. Thank you Sopra Steria for a fantastic collaboration with organizing this event, and a huge thank you to all the 55 participants from 30 different startups and 6 enterprise organizations. We would also like to […]

  • en person som sitter ved et skrivebord med en bærbar PC på et bord

    Hvordan tilrettelegge for dine ansatte i usikre tider

    Microsofts Max Tchapeyou tilbyr et veldig personlig synspunkt, med henvisning til de seks måtene han har funnet for å jobbe mer effektivt – og positivt – med teamet sitt.

Offentlig sektor

Utdanning

  • Skolens GDPR-guide 

    Skolens GDPR-guide 

    Skolens GDPR-guide Etter 25. mai* må du forholde deg til EUs regler rundt General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). For å forstå hvordan din skole skal klare dette, kan du ta en titt på denne e-boken og andre ressurser som kan være nyttig for deg og skolen din. Din skoles reise Skolen samler inn navn, adresser, fødselsdatoer […]

  • Universitetets GDPR-guide

    Universitetets GDPR-guide

    Etter 25. mai* må du forholde deg til EUs regler rundt General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). For å forstå hvordan ditt universitet skal klare dette, kan du ta en titt på denne e-boken og andre ressurser som kan være nyttig for deg og ditt universitet. Universitetets reise Universitetet samler inn navn, adresser, fødselsdatoer og mer […]

Oppdag flere relaterte artikler per dossier:

Digital Transformation

  • Sikker datalagring på norsk jord

    Sikker datalagring på norsk jord

    Høsten 2019 åpner Microsoft to nye datasenterregioner i Norge. Datasentrene tilbyr skytjenester til offentlige og private aktører med behov for og krav til lagring av data på norsk jord. Informasjonssikkerhet er helt nødvendig for alle verdiskapende aktører i vårt moderne samfunn. Når stadig flere avgjørelser baseres på en voksende mengde tilgjengelig informasjon, må vi kunne […]

Kundehistorier

Presse

  • Microsoft Norges respons til COVID-19

    Microsoft Norges respons til COVID-19

    Sist oppdatert: 16. mars 2020 Microsoft har en global tilnærming til beredskapsplaner og planlegging av krisehåndtering, som inkluderer både forutsette og uforutsette hendelser. Tilnærmingen inkluderer en handlingsplan ved pandemier. Våre handlingsplaner aktiveres over hele verden, og i tillegg til bistandsmidler til Kina og Puget Sound Community, har vi forpliktet oss til å levere produkter, tjenester […]

Sikkerhet og personvern

  • Woman with yellow hat stepping out of yellow cab with a Surface

    Det er på tide å gjøre "overalt" til det sikreste arbeidsstedet

    En fast kontorplass. På ett kontor. I samme del av byen. Slik er det ikke lenger. Vi er i bevegelse – helt bokstavelig. I dagens verden er det et større behov for å ha fleksibiliteten til å tenke, skape og dele – hvor som helst, når som helst. Og kunne gjøre det helt uten bekymringer. […]

Tips

  • Fem måter å holde ansatte engasjerte og produktive på

    Fem måter å holde ansatte engasjerte og produktive på

    De ansatte er bedriftens kraftigste konkurransefortrinn. Tar du de rette valgene for å få fullt utbytte av denne verdien – eller i det hele tatt beholde den? Hjelp de ansatte med å holde seg engasjerte, fornøyde og produktive Kun 13 % av dagens globale arbeidsstyrke er svært engasjert og svært fornøyd med sin arbeidsplass. Av de […]